FLOWSHOP WITH ZERO BUFFER MINIMIZING EARLINESS AND TARDINESS
Instance				Solutions		ZB1			ZB2
n	m	scen	seed	ZB1	ZB2	Time	Simplex It	B&B nodes	Time	Simplex It	B&B nodes
5	3	1	1	131	131	0.02	80	4	0.05	121	2
5	3	1	2	253	253	0.02	228	38	0.02	241	28
5	3	1	3	165	165	0.01	38	0	0.01	73	0
5	3	1	4	256	256	0.02	153	13	0.18	194	15
5	3	1	5	211	211	0.02	148	18	0.02	181	17
5	3	1	6	136	136	0.06	57	5	0.09	135	3
5	3	1	7	155	155	0.01	72	0	0.01	67	0
5	3	1	8	300	300	0.05	133	11	0.11	124	5
5	3	1	9	83	83	0.01	73	4	0.06	92	2
5	3	1	10	110	110	0.01	46	1	0.01	63	1
5	3	2	1	43	43	0.05	163	9	0.1	94	5
5	3	2	2	183	183	0.02	265	35	0.06	185	16
5	3	2	3	86	86	0.01	59	3	0.01	90	0
5	3	2	4	217	217	0.02	338	33	0.06	227	19
5	3	2	5	242	242	0.18	295	51	0.02	241	38
5	3	2	6	107	107	0.01	128	8	0.01	120	0
5	3	2	7	192	192	0.02	106	10	0.08	176	11
5	3	2	8	251	251	0.06	171	20	0.01	117	8
5	3	2	9	79	79	0.02	189	14	0.02	168	12
5	3	2	10	86	86	0.11	168	12	0.02	167	11
5	3	3	1	210	210	0.01	73	4	0.02	89	8
5	3	3	2	378	378	0.06	140	13	0.02	196	13
5	3	3	3	298	298	0.02	117	14	0.01	165	12
5	3	3	4	446	446	0.02	256	19	0.17	351	36
5	3	3	5	244	244	0.02	215	19	0.01	188	13
5	3	3	6	268	268	0.02	46	4	0.02	98	4
5	3	3	7	442	442	0.01	133	20	0.02	138	18
5	3	3	8	457	457	0.3	200	22	0.01	121	8
5	3	3	9	295	295	0.02	182	16	0.06	170	14
5	3	3	10	301	301	0.02	158	21	0.02	178	13
5	3	4	1	108	108	0.01	83	6	0.05	96	5
5	3	4	2	292	292	0.01	159	15	0.1	158	7
5	3	4	3	257	257	0.01	131	17	0.02	147	12
5	3	4	4	394	394	0.02	308	25	0.06	284	36
5	3	4	5	309	309	0.01	242	37	0.01	229	27
5	3	4	6	408	408	0.04	100	20	0.02	151	13
5	3	4	7	480	480	0.01	108	14	0.06	127	13
5	3	4	8	417	417	0.01	125	14	0.02	164	8
5	3	4	9	143	143	0.02	175	9	0.01	163	6
5	3	4	10	249	249	0.02	181	21	0.01	238	17
AVERAGE						0.03	151.05	15.48	0.04	158.18	11.90
TRIMMEAN (10%)						0.02	147.56	14.72	0.04	154.50	11.17
Instance				Solutions		ZB1			ZB2
n	m	scen	seed	ZB1	ZB2	Time	Simplex It	B&B nodes	Time	Simplex It	B&B nodes
10	3	1	1	555	555	0.22	1829	109	0.09	1334	66
10	3	1	2	960	960	0.84	12238	976	0.81	15160	930
10	3	1	3	594	594	1.07	14727	822	1.21	17110	867
10	3	1	4	703	703	0.17	4186	406	1.33	10150	643
10	3	1	5	733	733	0.28	7949	677	0.84	9962	633
10	3	1	6	884	884	0.54	8005	635	0.86	9714	653
10	3	1	7	712	712	0.78	11003	840	1.37	14565	881
10	3	1	8	819	819	0.21	1495	129	0.08	2192	148
10	3	1	9	828	828	0.54	7836	694	0.81	10296	663
10	3	1	10	599	599	0.21	4219	406	1.03	9539	569
10	3	2	1	274	274	0.36	10172	597	0.78	11466	590
10	3	2	2	612	612	0.51	9045	534	0.74	11150	588
10	3	2	3	555	555	1.91	31463	1346	0.38	8212	415
10	3	2	4	383	383	0.75	11143	606	1.47	14553	633
10	3	2	5	598	598	1.02	16827	951	0.4	4108	188
10	3	2	6	584	584	0.92	9653	760	0.73	12280	631
10	3	2	7	163	163	0.15	3904	251	0.14	3487	168
10	3	2	8	394	394	0.76	10310	565	0.4	14185	528
10	3	2	9	477	477	0.53	8660	579	0.77	10782	632
10	3	2	10	201	201	1.05	18831	778	0.8	11412	552
10	3	3	1	865	865	1.04	10973	822	0.94	17670	937
10	3	3	2	986	986	1.29	15454	1002	1.62	19016	1137
10	3	3	3	1134	1134	1.66	30081	1489	1.68	26992	1390
10	3	3	4	916	916	0.71	11926	765	0.93	12216	656
10	3	3	5	1094	1094	0.9	14363	902	1.49	17852	921
10	3	3	6	896	896	1.15	7943	647	0.79	10175	701
10	3	3	7	868	868	1.14	17316	1173	1.36	20512	1063
10	3	3	8	819	819	0.27	1346	134	0.09	2004	147
10	3	3	9	875	875	0.59	10153	733	1.05	13869	854
10	3	3	10	752	752	0.74	11501	751	0.88	13916	737
10	3	4	1	822	822	1.22	13599	885	1.66	22133	1123
10	3	4	2	619	619	0.63	11138	632	0.95	11533	573
10	3	4	3	1166	1166	1.3	23724	1270	1.87	29808	1319
10	3	4	4	786	786	1.32	25015	1115	1.22	17758	699
10	3	4	5	1401	1401	1.1	9768	663	1.41	16835	839
10	3	4	6	586	586	0.58	8592	676	1.16	10891	680
10	3	4	7	542	542	1.36	26117	1354	1.55	27310	1274
10	3	4	8	422	422	0.36	12459	632	0.72	13361	576
10	3	4	9	475	475	0.77	9414	601	0.93	10389	668
10	3	4	10	516	516	1.47	28174	1300	0.35	7185	338
AVERAGE						0.81	12563.78	755.18	0.94	13077.05	690.25
TRIMMEAN (10%)						0.79	12171.28	753.50	0.94	12850.72	685.78
Instance				Solutions		ZB1			ZB2
n	m	scen	seed	ZB1	ZB2	Time	Simplex It	B&B nodes	Time	Simplex It	B&B nodes
10	7	1	1	913	913	2.46	37182	1435	2.75	31217	1527
10	7	1	2	995	995	2.4	27592	1247	2.74	33486	1284
10	7	1	3	838	838	2	26439	897	2.57	33133	1043
10	7	1	4	1388	1388	2.4	34541	1550	2.43	33167	1531
10	7	1	5	1102	1102	1.85	27938	1107	2.3	28713	1269
10	7	1	6	696	696	1.15	15489	690	0.33	6238	306
10	7	1	7	1843	1843	3.84	62350	2034	5.26	71090	2675
10	7	1	8	480	480	0.25	6157	301	0.29	5449	272
10	7	1	9	1058	1058	2.52	34060	1389	2.72	30902	1273
10	7	1	10	1152	1152	2.41	32262	1262	2.97	37811	1413
10	7	2	1	1141	1141	2.07	37328	1562	3.72	41039	2042
10	7	2	2	1335	1335	2.75	42848	2133	2.85	38226	1575
10	7	2	3	987	987	5.33	92695	2677	4.46	51394	1525
10	7	2	4	1600	1600	1.36	18667	974	1.96	16497	866
10	7	2	5	1023	1023	3.61	37766	1557	2.86	30665	1380
10	7	2	6	240	240	1.44	19776	623	1.1	19175	651
10	7	2	7	2403	2403	3.42	56647	1866	4.11	44538	1722
10	7	2	8	231	231	0.76	19496	462	0.76	14766	352
10	7	2	9	857	857	3.5	47167	1307	2.62	32456	1098
10	7	2	10	1441	1441	2.13	31857	1151	2.89	34625	1273
10	7	3	1	1958	1958	2.84	39548	1742	2.73	28802	1549
10	7	3	2	1968	1968	2.27	33367	1459	2.63	26071	1305
10	7	3	3	2172	2172	6.68	111353	3672	10.31	114218	5032
10	7	3	4	2556	2556	1.36	23665	1228	1.66	23345	1007
10	7	3	5	2099	2099	2.99	47585	2036	5.32	59030	2880
10	7	3	6	1030	1030	3.32	50114	2073	5.88	89546	4387
10	7	3	7	2734	2734	3.23	50234	1940	3.32	44943	1745
10	7	3	8	1377	1377	1.59	23220	1059	2.36	27034	1348
10	7	3	9	2000	2000	4.84	66572	2774	5.14	59441	3006
10	7	3	10	2416	2416	5.06	73857	2736	4.58	60139	2685
10	7	4	1	2415	2415	2.23	40430	1731	2.08	31076	1239
10	7	4	2	2455	2455	2.77	44634	2189	3.45	38542	1992
10	7	4	3	2378	2378	5.72	98194	3310	5.69	81223	3313
10	7	4	4	3193	3193	1.44	21814	1112	1.47	23340	1028
10	7	4	5	2327	2327	2.61	35186	1552	3.13	34975	1677
10	7	4	6	347	347	2.28	22385	648	3.24	39998	723
10	7	4	7	3462	3462	2.54	36956	1386	3.36	42654	1681
10	7	4	8	1306	1306	1.91	16833	800	1.68	15827	747
10	7	4	9	2039	2039	3.4	52496	2279	4.07	54082	2402
10	7	4	10	3002	3002	2.91	46854	2026	3.72	44591	1987
AVERAGE						2.74	41088.85	1599.40	3.19	39336.60	1670.25
TRIMMEAN (10%)						2.67	39232.25	1561.97	3.08	37722.58	1578.14
Instance				Solutions		ZB1			ZB2
n	m	scen	seed	ZB1	ZB2	Time	Simplex It	B&B nodes	Time	Simplex It	B&B nodes
10	10	1	1	792	792	3.08	41330	1013	4.88	63446	1734
10	10	1	2	1881	1881	12.65	262667	8591	17.12	263090	9618
10	10	1	3	1255	1255	3.6	52684	1928	5.73	58705	2265
10	10	1	4	956	956	4.14	70586	1832	6.47	96177	2675
10	10	1	5	1861	1861	11.53	247547	8981	13.52	190295	6857
10	10	1	6	1364	1364	5.03	69950	2094	4.15	52316	1567
10	10	1	7	1686	1686	3.23	35928	1054	3.76	39157	1228
10	10	1	8	1148	1148	4.48	61044	1904	4.09	49177	1445
10	10	1	9	1191	1191	9.46	220028	6073	8.05	123554	3240
10	10	1	10	1795	1795	9.61	145825	4921	9.95	125590	4523
10	10	2	1	1070	1070	11.96	213359	3783	7.01	90849	2138
10	10	2	2	1767	1767	6.78	127036	3965	9.55	150496	4951
10	10	2	3	1944	1944	3.88	53152	1949	11.42	189004	5754
10	10	2	4	679	679	6.65	115028	1825	8.55	149057	2787
10	10	2	5	1906	1906	11.1	171036	4532	8.56	127610	4710
10	10	2	6	1610	1610	4.66	82020	2847	5.04	60674	1686
10	10	2	7	1791	1791	0.55	8962	342	2.32	21857	635
10	10	2	8	1252	1252	5.47	105017	2835	5.4	70061	1430
10	10	2	9	595	595	2.41	34057	1012	2.66	29890	751
10	10	2	10	2331	2331	6.42	93579	2961	6.77	83159	3178
10	10	3	1	2117	2117	3.47	42008	1102	3.44	32643	926
10	10	3	2	2884	2884	8.27	154692	5128	10.27	143841	5292
10	10	3	3	2855	2855	3.63	48436	1628	4.1	51047	1963
10	10	3	4	2246	2246	6.54	98702	2510	6.97	90834	2688
10	10	3	5	2832	2832	6.33	100462	3058	6.72	73185	2775
10	10	3	6	2870	2870	10.05	182605	6056	11.06	156031	6359
10	10	3	7	2934	2934	0.66	10745	446	3.36	24280	827
10	10	3	8	2836	2836	10.4	202214	6570	11.67	159865	6919
10	10	3	9	1728	1728	3.5	44876	1404	4.29	53439	1544
10	10	3	10	3246	3246	5.76	88347	3227	5.75	70197	3132
10	10	4	1	2271	2271	4.15	58161	1807	4.89	54642	1877
10	10	4	2	2919	2919	7.5	141285	4966	7.77	116465	3967
10	10	4	3	3536	3536	3.46	58718	2358	5.64	56781	2491
10	10	4	4	1907	1907	5.83	95095	2507	10.55	131533	3632
10	10	4	5	2967	2967	6.77	102730	3010	6.22	66303	2162
10	10	4	6	3267	3267	9.5	172843	6069	9.49	134783	6056
10	10	4	7	3359	3359	0.55	9962	419	2.39	19468	678
10	10	4	8	2726	2726	8.38	157956	5635	8.47	121515	5455
10	10	4	9	1261	1261	5.55	87741	1750	6.01	75992	1785
10	10	4	10	3975	3975	6.86	106376	4346	8.32	100651	4789
AVERAGE						6.10	104369.73	3210.95	7.06	94191.48	3212.23
TRIMMEAN (10%)						6.06	101268.08	3058.47	6.86	90915.25	3073.31
Instance				Solutions		ZB1			ZB2
n	m	scen	seed	ZB1	ZB2	Time	Simplex It	B&B nodes	Time	Simplex It	B&B nodes
15	3	1	1	1312	1312	2.4	34700	1462	4.82	64445	3138
15	3	1	2	1510	1510	8.47	117162	5000	4.99	75061	3954
15	3	1	3	2084	2084	10.76	229510	8741	7.8	143708	5987
15	3	1	4	1579	1579	3.34	61301	3531	2.77	42276	2715
15	3	1	5	1202	1202	2.37	42059	1618	2.95	37648	1131
15	3	1	6	1392	1392	3.46	52577	2213	3.68	50014	1610
15	3	1	7	1501	1501	5.63	138334	6898	6.42	144909	5719
15	3	1	8	1501	1501	7.93	194955	12084	16.98	235303	14027
15	3	1	9	1627	1627	2.68	53620	2189	3.55	50946	2746
15	3	1	10	1326	1326	3.98	87031	3624	5.23	94096	2770
15	3	2	1	253	253	4.83	106662	4205	9.93	127947	4176
15	3	2	2	686	686	23.52	396469	9699	18.64	283442	9982
15	3	2	3	1175	1175	9.87	131767	6265	5.81	89134	4230
15	3	2	4	308	308	4.17	89231	3087	12.95	198771	7349
15	3	2	5	465	465	28.28	559348	23568	63.78	986127	36532
15	3	2	6	318	318	14.91	289168	10850	15.17	271322	7934
15	3	2	7	390	390	10.95	171179	7784	10.46	158221	6910
15	3	2	8	700	700	33.5	685198	26705	43.06	634399	23907
15	3	2	9	907	907	13.94	263147	7721	11.88	201501	8395
15	3	2	10	392	392	20.18	455697	11890	18.44	339458	8543
15	3	3	1	1313	1313	2.45	32622	1252	3.63	57853	2075
15	3	3	2	1755	1755	5.16	100329	3920	6.6	101624	4826
15	3	3	3	2139	2139	9.26	193720	9659	13.59	221877	12409
15	3	3	4	1752	1752	7.03	182450	8353	9	188040	6305
15	3	3	5	1478	1478	9.25	202360	7465	6.3	111423	4999
15	3	3	6	1390	1390	2.87	48383	1872	2.75	42954	1510
15	3	3	7	1772	1772	40.87	709022	43905	26.96	465535	31027
15	3	3	8	1668	1668	16.55	447355	25283	27.45	433385	23943
15	3	3	9	2088	2088	4.41	65170	3052	5.47	96937	3270
15	3	3	10	1327	1327	3.14	58819	2145	3.42	44352	1787
15	3	4	1	358	358	12.5	292938	8549	15.78	239697	8326
15	3	4	2	1949	1949	127.87	2109292	88892	122.66	1883719	101717
15	3	4	3	1252	1252	9.11	180191	6529	11.13	191762	7027
15	3	4	4	790	790	32.18	852690	32798	88.69	1296564	56487
15	3	4	5	1021	1021	55.76	1262984	40447	95.07	1524564	48534
15	3	4	6	872	872	41.47	626460	12705	25.4	387175	12045
15	3	4	7	1306	1306	232.95	3413269	133385	102.01	1641446	76897
15	3	4	8	1585	1585	135.43	2542364	72592	230.92	3553371	118377
15	3	4	9	2297	2297	10.47	205510	10401	11.94	206547	12582
15	3	4	10	767	767	131.13	2484159	92933	40.61	532770	15339
AVERAGE						27.63	504230.05	19131.78	27.97	436258.08	17780.93
TRIMMEAN (10%)						20.33	392951.31	14895.53	21.10	331480.81	13569.50
Instance				Solutions		ZB1			ZB2
n	m	scen	seed	ZB1	ZB2	Time	Simplex It	B&B nodes	Time	Simplex It	B&B nodes
15	7	1	1	1026	1026	21.05	384642	11001	25.27	330103	9731
15	7	1	2	1317	1317	55.15	1032999	32684	144.27	2100387	60570
15	7	1	3	1798	1798	173.57	3340246	109525	209.43	3168056	104035
15	7	1	4	1590	1590	135.03	2918910	89763	145.51	2368198	73811
15	7	1	5	1917	1917	23.72	417329	10883	23.77	323330	8741
15	7	1	6	2264	2264	105.19	2247751	49644	114.6	1859562	44253
15	7	1	7	2031	2031	203.84	4388037	110140	295.86	4790512	134651
15	7	1	8	1064	1064	15.5	271130	7388	29.67	403099	10978
15	7	1	9	1818	1818	6.37	95911	4004	11.21	144047	5647
15	7	1	10	1690	1690	27.67	538395	15988	48.07	754570	23499
15	7	2	1	632	632	41.39	736262	11309	17.81	216214	2698
15	7	2	2	1076	1076	193.39	2550378	22515	57.47	723953	10137
15	7	2	3	1852	1852	170.79	2823896	75503	346.19	5093490	136065
15	7	2	4	965	965	782.96	12313413	214741	462.56	6326319	119216
15	7	2	5	761	761	44.9	869807	18069	23.95	319631	6945
15	7	2	6	1654	1654	683.54	9852869	163481	1017.78	15802930	424526
15	7	2	7	1510	1510	93.29	1726402	42753	147.42	2179567	56923
15	7	2	8	520	520	107.03	1827401	20972	52.75	679031	12089
15	7	2	9	561	561	33.43	663300	15121	48.84	675826	13683
15	7	2	10	1150	1150	284.26	3960539	80805	114.53	1629363	31245
15	7	3	1	2226	2226	103.95	1493298	31892	93.84	1317460	40280
15	7	3	2	2799	2799	84.59	1254964	24935	97.6	1248676	34754
15	7	3	3	3753	3753	760.42	14130210	478807	788.93	11937786	472834
15	7	3	4	2849	2849	113.55	1868734	48573	113.12	1566449	52434
15	7	3	5	2917	2917	222.27	3601588	82824	161.83	2173657	60212
15	7	3	6	3782	3782	785.49	11854756	215568	632.61	9055035	220608
15	7	3	7	3256	3256	67.58	974160	22867	67.39	837733	22100
15	7	3	8	2170	2170	163.51	2513832	54155	175.14	2424512	71790
15	7	3	9	2840	2840	69.4	1239895	34788	95.83	1420832	45068
15	7	3	10	3563	3563	257.56	5039116	129479	271.42	4198118	124560
15	7	4	1	2099	2099	490.37	7291741	138810	459.03	6327819	137675
15	7	4	2	2610	2610	117.81	1631454	29013	165.55	2421151	55573
15	7	4	3	4560	4560	516.33	9020295	335550	416.7	6410449	320137
15	7	4	4	2720	2720	195.07	3504601	101975	138.32	2008915	55734
15	7	4	5	2479	2479	178.91	2652566	53884	136.95	1968753	53018
15	7	4	6	3817	3817	372.98	6652980	165662	408.77	5946348	165950
15	7	4	7	3907	3907	132.96	2465851	65324	202.72	2960971	87472
15	7	4	8	2042	2042	1743.52	17713490	188408	635.89	9169665	158730
15	7	4	9	2021	2021	76.99	1190058	29037	77.94	1070277	33044
15	7	4	10	3838	3838	205.84	3209804	67068	155.79	2396200	70966
AVERAGE						246.53	3806575.25	85122.70	215.81	3168724.85	89309.55
TRIMMEAN (10%)						203.06	3334785.25	71643.31	188.79	2740222.69	74074.36
Instance				Solutions		ZB1			ZB2
n	m	scen	seed	ZB1	ZB2	Time	Simplex It	B&B nodes	Time	Simplex It	B&B nodes
15	10	1	1	998	998	98.01	1171293	19767	56.06	722631	12651
15	10	1	2	2817	2817	1527.4	28225328	698305	3939.05	57166435	1478343
15	10	1	3	2836	2836	711.04	12261348	226338	884.06	11708848	252452
15	10	1	4	2259	2259	437.68	8251319	197454	649.43	9846267	247819
15	10	1	5	2119	2119	236.02	4171358	96257	152.81	2037636	47187
15	10	1	6	1818	1818	105	2016594	51496	127.03	1827384	43819
15	10	1	7	1905	1905	538.5	9659165	205862	1168.66	17928157	428823
15	10	1	8	2664	2664	924.55	15750111	339980	903.11	12416958	294390
15	10	1	9	2556	2556	726.04	13325542	348222	538.01	7534730	220861
15	10	1	10	1792	1792	160.45	2702394	57488	240.27	3271828	70466
15	10	2	1	1068	1068	147.39	2589515	25013	407.46	6315488	131238
15	10	2	2	2452	2452	719.62	10297617	179057	424.67	5812183	128094
15	10	2	3	3291	3291	618.77	8272726	103198	386.69	5231631	97964
15	10	2	4	2398	2398	321.51	4106614	41314	863.36	11524279	182001
15	10	2	5	1452	1452	211.83	2884706	21609	135.55	1784503	21688
15	10	2	6	512	512	36.64	621509	7305	66.5	724807	9737
15	10	2	7	943	943	123.21	1552431	21664	113.82	1559608	21632
15	10	2	8	2885	2885	1047.13	15366957	253418	1064.86	14605062	305542
15	10	2	9	2858	2858	54.85	871920	32474	133.97	1567132	36627
15	10	2	10	2194	2194	110.82	1661788	51104	292.26	3692734	133632
15	10	3	1	3023	3023	236	3049914	39415	195.7	2490353	53519
15	10	3	2	4760	4760	1454.96	21623328	355909	1257.31	16478078	371368
15	10	3	3	5163	5163	2717.5	39532474	626237	1986.18	26788809	604155
15	10	3	4	4544	4544	843.6	13848836	283119	807.74	10839688	240890
15	10	3	5	4151	4151	684	9198940	139806	608.23	7650155	149108
15	10	3	6	3303	3303	532.27	8703363	202329	679.42	8782953	229181
15	10	3	7	3770	3770	879.81	11737960	172727	531.31	6489174	138420
15	10	3	8	5303	5303	1957.81	29579516	511026	1495.05	19063366	460197
15	10	3	9	4602	4602	404.93	6182921	188706	311.84	3936342	125848
15	10	3	10	4331	4331	59.15	881751	24048	48.26	516359	18890
15	10	4	1	2823	2823	3096.09	26939001	213068	729.93	9766377	122746
15	10	4	2	4774	4774	1012.47	15553711	326629	1395.36	18321669	427716
15	10	4	3	5912	5912	2822.88	41972025	673673	2152.51	30636531	687325
15	10	4	4	5438	5438	394.32	6268905	123962	503.51	6578415	146562
15	10	4	5	3838	3838	1032.42	15258229	248603	960.77	13189472	264089
15	10	4	6	2622	2622	629.73	10496838	248016	748.29	9398071	234750
15	10	4	7	3001	3001	362.03	4733720	76906	851.05	11234055	244863
15	10	4	8	6087	6087	933.53	13971582	256813	792.57	10107130	229210
15	10	4	9	5880	5880	285.23	4535663	163735	208.05	2617128	126457
15	10	4	10	5743	5743	60.71	844984	23463	59.01	636561	23403
AVERAGE						731.40	10766847.40	196887.88	721.74	9819974.68	226591.58
TRIMMEAN (10%)						645.71	9658414.00	179901.81	629.83	8440086.14	190989.08
Instance				Solutions		ZB1			ZB2
n	m	scen	seed	ZB1	ZB2	Time	Simplex It	B&B nodes	Time	Simplex It	B&B nodes
20	3	1	1	2459	2459	199.37	2278071	101924	450.64	2861689	150475
20	3	1	2	2611	2611	133.71	2376434	82494	157.58	2371915	102131
20	3	1	3	2649	2649	92.08	1750219	72401	107.93	1501501	58359
20	3	1	4	2603	2603	35.3	696740	36623	29.68	503320	20699
20	3	1	5	3001	3001	153.43	3646527	103496	139.43	1969837	82136
20	3	1	6	3184	3184	48.25	803478	23945	27.72	418532	15836
20	3	1	7	2622	2622	228.5	3697046	167131	151.4	2526298	133614
20	3	1	8	3044	3044	30.37	727942	31374	60.8	789155	42953
20	3	1	9	2780	2780	22.9	484526	13223	22.15	410468	12108
20	3	1	10	3193	3193	64.27	1174508	61458	64.09	752988	44881
20	3	2	1	918	918	555.73	8573681	341586	3694.49	47287292	1772706
20	3	2	2	1597	1597	1221.72	19844377	516205	993	15561791	470831
20	3	2	3	559	559	347.91	5960003	135472	250.88	3819295	66564
20	3	2	4	545	545	226.92	4410886	99227	199.46	3395612	64935
20	3	2	5	1064	1064	1365.42	24884106	1025175	676.58	10432712	417937
20	3	2	6	1541	1541	11.72	171907	6694	15.02	165483	6621
20	3	2	7	777	777	765.45	11709959	453501	812.67	9882897	402852
20	3	2	8	1258	1258	123.55	2334790	119939	110.75	1734580	87834
20	3	2	9	988	988	72.05	1198559	26443	78.09	1167227	35149
20	3	2	10	1310	1310	97.16	1811849	78813	105.17	1523119	86159
20	3	3	1	2976	2976	240.68	4158149	165022	250.5	3547728	184809
20	3	3	2	3335	3335	1192.42	20359376	649405	836.07	12763273	541100
20	3	3	3	2786	2786	184.38	3091261	122350	170.56	2502935	100165
20	3	3	4	2781	2781	63.4	653395	35569	35.13	496675	36542
20	3	3	5	3064	3064	215.17	5459864	144212	133.76	2094795	82172
20	3	3	6	3181	3181	54.05	883635	27885	35.01	480148	21032
20	3	3	7	2887	2887	634.14	11540861	501547	382.45	6048472	304289
20	3	3	8	3068	3068	34.96	667251	30935	38.88	555580	24199
20	3	3	9	2885	2885	45.88	845113	31811	65.04	973336	39971
20	3	3	10	3706	3706	315.86	5403216	250552	313.08	4473147	208318
20	3	4	1	2981	2981	4558.37	74528472	3456586	2912.01	34593952	1909924
20	3	4	2	3495	3495	3433.8	54696303	2148635	1954.31	27127447	1267680
20	3	4	3	1390	1390	6054.38	46060139	629578	1967.14	31404424	836912
20	3	4	4	2112	2112	477.15	5917371	427950	155.59	1822597	114430
20	3	4	5	1534	1534	3698.04	58275916	1668079	3028	49831435	1907123
20	3	4	6	1591	1591	17.17	226825	8943	12.78	152322	5828
20	3	4	7	2677	2677	2072.1	27242847	1554243	1303.94	15882504	881846
20	3	4	8	2589	2589	364.15	6017068	318629	394.48	5098944	218323
20	3	4	9	1637	1637	539.57	9199764	269670	677.88	9660745	263665
20	3	4	10	3494	3494	743.73	11941404	454714	426.34	6393892	305602
AVERAGE						768.38	11142595.95	409835.98	581.01	8124501.55	333217.75
TRIMMEAN (10%)						558.15	8680575.50	299238.36	458.06	6320653.61	263867.06